Which Gym should i go to?

Here's the situation: So my parents got me a 2 year all sport pass to 24 hour fitness for Christmas, but they said they can return it no problem, if i decide to get a YMCA pass instead. 24 hour is pretty close to my house, and I can walk there in about 15-20 minutes. It is also notably cheaper than the YMCA pass. Many people from my school go there, and i could also walk there after school in about 15 minutes. The YMCA is a more expensive pass, and is about 4 miles from my house and it would take me hours to walk there (not just a flat road, many hills and obstacles). The Gym is nice, but it's also a place where many old people and annoying ladies work out. However, all my friends have passes to the YMCA, and it's more fun and easier to work out with friends. One of my friends can give me rides there until the end of summer, in three months when i get my license. Please help me decide which gym to go with and tell me why. Think of yourself in my position, and don't just say the gym you go to.